i want to compare and contrast two short stories to make into an essay, but i have no idea where to start. i answered questions that are supposed to be discussion points and now need to combine them and make it all flow. See summary to know what the stories are about; questions follow after. Any advice is greatly appreciated, thanks
Summary:
Drew Hayden Taylor’s “Cry me a River, White Boy”: This story speaks of the reflection on reconciliation and the residential schools, the apology made by the government, and the misguided policies of politicians when it comes to people of another race. The story reflects back on the history of Residential Schools in Canada, where over 150,000 Indigenous children were forcibly taken away from their families and shipped off to one of 130-plus schools scattered across seven provinces and two territories. These children were robbed of their language, their beliefs, their self-respect, their culture, and, in some cases, their very existence in a vain attempt to make them more Canadian. The author speaks of the long-awaited apology made by the government, which was received with a lot of emotion and seen as a cathartic cry for many people.
Mike Degagne’s “I’m Sorry”: Mike DeGagne discusses the importance of apologies in the age of reconciliation, reflecting on how public institutions use apologies, and how they can be either uplifting or shabby. Apologies are an important part of the process of reconciliation between Indigenous people and settlers/settler governments. In the age of reconciliation, the importance of apologies is becoming more and more evident, as public institutions are recognizing the power of expressing sincere apologies and remorse. In his story, he reflects on how public institutions have adopted this idea of apology and how it allows them to stand in a spotlight of grace and dignity. He also discusses the importance of apology being sincere, and of using it to describe the actions taken, and to express understanding of the harm that resulted.
1. What does the author say about the apology:
Drew Hayden Taylor’s “Cry me a River, White Boy”: The author says that the apology made by the government was eagerly awaited and was received with a lot of emotion. It was also seen as a cathartic cry for many people. The author speaks of how the apology made by the government was eagerly awaited by the people, with televisions being set up in community centres, band offices, halls, and schools in Indigenous communities all across the country. Upon the apology being made, the people cried, both out of memory of what had been done as well as out of relief that the government was taking responsibility for its actions. This event made a lot of people cry, and for many, it was a good cry- a cathartic one. Psychiatrists and Elders have spoken of the healing power of such an apology.
Mike Degagne’s “I’m Sorry”: The author states that public institutions have discovered the wisdom of apology and that it allows those offering apology to stand in a spotlight of grace and dignity. He also suggest that it is important for apology to be sincere, and that it should be used to describe actions taken and express understanding of the harm that resulted.
2. Do the apologies seem sincere to you:
Drew Hayden Taylor’s “Cry me a River, White Boy”: The apologies made by the government seem sincere, given that they were eagerly awaited and met with strong emotion. This event made a lot of people cry, and for many, it was a good cry- a cathartic one. This is indicative of the sincerity of the apology, as it was seen as a healing experience for many people. Furthermore, the government took the necessary steps of acknowledging the wrongs of the past and taking responsibility for them, which is a key part of the healing process.
Mike Degagne’s “I’m Sorry”: Apologies should be sincere, and should be used to describe the actions taken and the harm that resulted. Apologies should be seen as a way of transforming relationships and acknowledging the gravity of the past, and should not be seen as a form of penance. Apologies should be seen as a way of repairing the broken trust between Indigenous people and settlers/settler governments and allowing for the healing of past wrongs.
3. Content and Tone:
Drew Hayden Taylor’s “Cry me a River, White Boy”: The content and tone of this story is reflective and sorrowful, as it speaks of the unjust policies imposed on Indigenous people. The author speaks of how the children were forcibly taken away from their families and shipped off to residential schools, where they were robbed of their language, their beliefs, their self-respect, their culture, and, in some cases, their very existence. The author also speaks of the misguided policies of politicians when it comes to people of another race, such as the Chinese head tax and the sending of an Inuit community five hundred kilometres further north in an attempt to establish Arctic sovereignty.
Mike Degagne’s “I’m Sorry”: The content and tone of Mike DeGagné’s story is reflective and thoughtful. (I don’t know how to expand here)
4. Are the modern, contemporary apologies an effect way of helping to reconcile Indigenous people settlers/settlers government:
Drew Hayden Taylor’s “Cry me a River, White Boy”: Yes, the modern, contemporary apologies are an effective way of helping to reconcile Indigenous people settlers/settlers government, as it acknowledges the wrongs of past policies and provides a path for healing and reconciliation. The modern, contemporary apologies are an effective way of helping to reconcile Indigenous people settlers/settlers government, as it acknowledges the wrongs of past policies and provides a path for healing and reconciliation. The apology made by the government was eagerly awaited and was received with a lot of emotion, which is indicative of its effectiveness. By acknowledging the wrongs of the past and taking responsibility for them, the government has provided a path for healing and reconciliation. Furthermore, the apology has allowed for the healing of the deep wounds inflicted by the Residential School system and the other misguided policies and has allowed for a new chapter in the relationship between Indigenous people and the government.
Mike Degagne’s “I’m Sorry”: Apologies are a part of the process of reconciliation and can be an effective way of helping to reconcile Indigenous people and settlers/settler governments, though they may not be enough on their own. Apologies can also be an effective way of helping to reconcile Indigenous people and settlers/settler governments, though they may not be enough on their own. It is important to recognize that apologies are only the beginning of the reconciliation process, and that they must be followed up with meaningful action. Apologies should be seen as a way of creating a new relationship between Indigenous people and settlers/settler governments and of restoring the trust and respect that was lost. It is also important to consider how the apology is received. How do recipients hear, feel, and use apology to restore what was lost? It is vital to ensure that the apology is meaningful and that it is seen as an effort to reconcile the situation. An apology should be seen as an opportunity for growth and understanding, and for the rebuilding of relationships. It is also important to remember that apologies do not provide an immediate solution to the issues at hand. Apologies may be necessary, but they are not the only step in the reconciliation process. It is important to remember that apologies should be followed up with meaningful action, and that they should be seen as a way of transformation and rebuilding relationships rather than a form of penance. In conclusion, apologies can be an effective way of helping to reconcile Indigenous people and settlers/settler governments, though they may not be enough on their own. It is important to ensure that apologies are sincere and meaningful, and to remember that they should be followed up with meaningful action. Apologies should be seen as a way of transforming relationships and restoring the trust and respect that was lost, and as an opportunity for growth and understanding.
We are a professional custom writing website. If you have searched a question and bumped into our website just know you are in the right place to get help in your coursework.
Yes. We have posted over our previous orders to display our experience. Since we have done this question before, we can also do it for you. To make sure we do it perfectly, please fill our Order Form. Filling the order form correctly will assist our team in referencing, specifications and future communication.
1. Click on the “Place order tab at the top menu or “Order Now” icon at the bottom and a new page will appear with an order form to be filled.
2. Fill in your paper’s requirements in the "PAPER INFORMATION" section and click “PRICE CALCULATION” at the bottom to calculate your order price.
3. Fill in your paper’s academic level, deadline and the required number of pages from the drop-down menus.
4. Click “FINAL STEP” to enter your registration details and get an account with us for record keeping and then, click on “PROCEED TO CHECKOUT” at the bottom of the page.
5. From there, the payment sections will show, follow the guided payment process and your order will be available for our writing team to work on it.
Need this assignment or any other paper?
Click here and claim 25% off
Discount code SAVE25